Sylvia Benjamin

At Sylvia Benajmin State Farm we love serving customers throughout Michiana and helping them with their auto, home, renters, life, business, and health insurance needs. Every household is different, and our team is committed to providing personal service, answering questions, and making it easy to review coverage options as life changes. We provide your personal price plan!

Fall is here in Elkhart County! Bringing cooler weather, changing leaves, football, festivals, and plenty of activity throughout our community. Sylvia Benjamin serves individuals, families, and businesses throughout Indiana, Michigan, Ohio with auto, home, renters, life, health, and business insurance. If something has changed in your household, our team is here to answer questions and help you review your insurance options.

Hello, I’m Sylvia Benjamin, your local State Farm agent here in Nappanee! I’m a wife, a proud mom of two amazing adult kids, a Veteran of the United States Army, and a long-time small business owner who loves serving our communities across Elkhart County, St. Joseph County, Kosciusko County, Lagrange County, and throughout Indiana, Ohio, and Michigan.

To me, being a Good Neighbor is more than just a saying. It represents genuine compassion, local involvement, and meaningful service. I care deeply about uplifting our communities, supporting our customers, and encouraging the growth of each team member who joins Team Benjamin. Our history of giving back is part of who we are, and our foundation is built on shared values, integrity, and a true commitment to great service. Team Benjamin strives to uplift others, encourage professional and personal growth, and stay engaged in community outreach all year long—especially during the winter months, when neighbors often appreciate a little extra support.

I am a Desert Storm Veteran and a graduate of the University of Maryland. I proudly serve on the Board for the Boys & Girls Club of Nappanee and have previously served on the Board for the Boys & Girls Club of Elkhart County and currently serving on the Nappanee Board for the Boys & Girls Club. Our team remains active with youth programs across the region and continues to support local students through internships and enrichment opportunities.

I’m also a member of the American Legion of Nappanee and serve on the Honor Guard. Our team actively participates Boys & Girls Club of Elkhart County and especially our local Boys & Girls Club in Nappanee. We love programs that empower young people, families, and local organizations. I am the Co-Founder of LeadHERship Circle, a community group supporting women leaders and business owners, and I proudly serve in Personal Relations with The Rose Garden Recovery in Syracuse. I am also chair for Wings and Wheels for the Nappanee Apple Festival . I serve on the Proverbs 31 Women of Strength board we serve over 400 State Farm Agents across the country to empower strong women in their personal lives and the life of being a State Farm Agent and business owner. I love bringing neighbors together during community events. We also are a sponsor the 4H Elkhart County Fair, one of the largest County fairs in the nation!

Our office proudly assists customers in nearby towns, including Goshen, Bremen, Wakarusa, Syracuse, Middlebury, Warsaw, Plymouth, Mishawaka, South Bend, and the surrounding areas. Whether you’re new to the region or preparing for a relocation, we would be glad to help make your transition easier.

We welcome you to contact our State Farm office for FREE car insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, and FREE life insurance quotes. We also assist with business insurance needs and fleets. With winter weather continuing, our team can also help you explore coverage options for your snowmobile, ATV, UTV, winter recreational vehicle, or seasonal equipment—perfect for this time of year.

At Sylvia Benjamin State Farm, we consider ourselves a family. Our goal is to help you explore insurance options that fit your life, your household, and your priorities. With more than 135 years of combined insurance and customer service experience, our 9-member team is ready to welcome you with warmth, kindness, and steady guidance through the small and big seasons of your life.

Offering FREE insurance quotes for car insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, and life insurance—to help you review your policies as the new year gets underway.

🚗 Helping drivers explore auto insurance options across Nappanee, Elkhart, Goshen, Warsaw, Syracuse, Plymouth, and surrounding areas.

🏡 Supporting homeowners and renters with helpful information on home insurance and renters insurance throughout the winter season.

❤️ Providing life insurance quotes to help families explore coverage options as they begin a new year.

Ready to assist with seasonal recreational vehicles, Boats, ATVs, and jet skis, RVS so you’re prepared for beautiful spring and summer in Indiana, Ohio, and Michigan.

📍 Proudly serving customers throughout Elkhart County, St. Joseph County, Kosciusko County, and Lagrange County, as well as nearby cities like Mishawaka, Bremen, Wakarusa, Middlebury, and South Bend.

🤝 Giving back to the community year-round through programs like Big Brothers Big Sisters, Boys & Girls Clubs, LeadHERship Circle, The Rose Garden Recovery, and our schools in Wanee, Bremen, Fairfield, Warsaw, Triton and ongoing community involvement.

⭐ Bringing over 135 years of team experience to help neighbors explore insurance choices with confidence, especially during this time of year when many households review policies.

🤝 Committed to serving local families, supporting small business owners, and strengthening connections throughout Nappanee and the surrounding region.